Quote:
In other words, the onus is on Alex to prove Roberts is not a jew.
|
No, because while you can prove that someone is a Jew. It is almost impossible to prove someone is not Jewish. If there is validity in Jewish gene DNA testing, then that might be the only plausible way to prove racial Jewishness or lack-there-of.
Quote:
In other words, Ivan is the only one providing rational argument, and Alex gives no justification for his opinion.
Ivan says it in a cleverer way, but that's what he's saying. Is he right?
|
Yes and no. It is not that black and white. Yes, in far as in the under tone of every propaganda effort should be the basic message Jews= Bad; The problem being when the importance, or emphasis is placed on the "physical Jew" = Bad, the deadly aspect of the Jew escapes, that of the" ideological Jew" I see many people going down the road of Jew= Bad, but meanwhile they are engulfed in Jewish behavior, ideology, etc essentially making them "spiritual" Jews. So Jews= Bad but emphasis needs to be Jewish Ideology, beliefs makes Jews= bad, and you make it stick, with Jews have said ideologies as a part of their genetic make-up, of passing personality traits, group evolution strategy etc, or to the religious side (Christians, any other non-Jew membership dominated religion) because of their Talmud, and Torah.