View Single Post
Old June 12th, 2010 #14
Gibson
.
 
Gibson's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,718
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by I v a n View Post
I shall not go into the swamp of discussing what exactly constitutes a proof for that would probably not serve any useful purpose, but I would like to ask (I hope that's not a bannable offense): do you know what Roberts ethnicity is without any reasonable doubt? If so, could you share it with us, please, if not how can you be sure that he is not a jew?
In other words, the onus is on Alex to prove Roberts is not a jew.

Quote:
Originally Posted by I v a n View Post
About All that does is confuse the very people we need to alert and persuade. They need, above all else, a clear, consistent, unmistakable message: jew = bad. You can do that in many different ways. You can just repeat that jew = bad million times, and that would probably be good enough for the majority of the population, or you could try to explain with the patience that it requires why jew = bad .
In other words, Ivan is the only one providing rational argument, and Alex gives no justification for his opinion.

Ivan says it in a cleverer way, but that's what he's saying. Is he right?