View Single Post
Old October 25th, 2008 #1625
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Default

Nafcash has a new challenge for Shermer.

First a little background. (The following information can be found on page 128 of Shermer’s deluding piece of trash – Denying History.) This is what Michael Shermer claims he believes about the holocaust:

Column one - the name of the camp.

Column two - the original death toll claim.

Column three - the total number of alleged deaths that Shermer is denying / has revised downward.

Column four - the new - REVISED - death toll claim (historical revision) being made by Shermer.

Column five - the percent of these holocausts that Shermer is denying.


1 – Majdanek - 1.5 million - minus 1.440 = .060 - Shermer denies 96% of this alleged holocaust within the holocaust

2 – Belzec - 3.0 million - minus 2.400 = .600 - Shermer denies 80% of this alleged holocaust within the holocaust

3 – Auschwitz - 4.0 million - minus 2.90 = 1.100 - Shermer denies 72.5% of this alleged holocaust within the holocaust

4 – Treblinka - 3.0 million - minus 2.10 = .900 - Shermer denies 70% of this alleged holocaust within the holocaust

5 – Chelmno - .320 million - minus .168 = .152 - Shermer denies 52.5% of this alleged holocaust within the holocaust

6 – Sobibor - .250 million - minus .000 = .250 - Shermer denies 0.0% of this alleged holocaust within the holocaust

Totals - 12.070 million - minus 9.008 = 3.062 - Shermer denies 75% of the jews alleged claims about the holocaust


Now we all know that Shermer has cravenly refused to accept nafcash’s - THE FINAL SOLUTION FORENSIC CHALLENGE. ($100,000.00 reward for locating / proving the existence of just one “huge mass grave” that contains just 1/10th of 1% of the alleged mass murder at Sobibor or Treblinka - see http://www.nafcash.com/ for more specific details.) So we are now going to make things even easier for him.

The above information begs the following question:

Shermer admits that 75 percent of the other two “Action Reinhardt” camps of Belzec and Treblinka didn't happen (And don’t forget, Shermer is known, even amongst the exterminationists / holocaustians – as a high counter.); so why then does he espouse that 100 % of the alleged Sobibor holocaust happened?


Now, Shermer's challenge:


Can you locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation." (Saponification)

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.


?????

Huh? Can you Mike?

Just one?

Just how hard should that be to do Mike?


Remember what Shermer said in Denying History:

“The culmination of years of research… Our purpose... To refute Holocaust denial... To debunk the deniers, can’t we just go there and see them for ourselves? The answer of course, is “yes.” We traveled to the camps themselves, to… Sobibor… to test the claims [of the "deniers"] that no mass murders took place... Many of our arguments draw on specialized research into the claims of the deniers that took us to the Nazi extermination camps themselves… We went to Europe to conduct research at the camps, in particular at… Sobibor… We wanted to see for ourselves just what evidence there is at the camps and to take the opportunity to examine firsthand the claims… In order to make proper interpretations; we must review the physical evidence… Like criminologists solving a crime… How is it that so much physical evidence can come to be doubted?”


Shermer is also being challengd to answer the following questions:

On what EXACT date(s) were you physically in the Sobibor camp?

Why won’t you publish so much as a single photo that proves that you actually stepped foot in the camp?

Why do you refuse to publish the results of your alleged Sobibor “investigation?”

Just what do you mean when you say that you “tested the claims that no mass murder took place” at Sobibor?

Just what kind of "research" did you conduct at Sobibor?

When are you going to publish the results?

Just what did you end up “seeing for yourself” at the Sobibor camp?

Just what do you mean when you say you “examined firsthand the claims?”

Just how exactly did you come to believe that 80% of the Belzec holocaust didn’t happen and 70% of the Treblinka holocaust didn’t happen, but 100% of the Sobibor holocaust did happen?

And just what led you to believe that 75% of the alleged Belzec and Treblinka holocausts didn’t happen?

Why do you refuse to accept THE FINAL SOLUTION FORENSIC CHALLENGE?

Why can’t you locate / prove the existence of just one “huge mass grave” at Sobibor?

Why do you refuse to answer these simple, reasonable and logical questions from REAL skeptics?

What are you afraid of Mike?

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; October 26th, 2008 at 12:03 PM.