Is There Such a Thing as a Good Jew?

[I v a n]

What's the common trait shared by the members of the following group of people: Norman Finkelstein, Gilad Atzmon, Israel Shamir, Israel Shahak, Paul Craig Roberts, Alan Hart, Lord Monckton, except that all are jews. Perhaps some would dispute that Alan Hart and the good Lord are jews (for example, the 'j' word does not appear even once on Lord Monckton's Wiki page), but my intuition tells me otherwise. Compare the heavyset look with eyes popping out they both share with Nadezhda Krupskaya, Lenin's wife:






Many would be tempted to say that these jews are the good jews, without any quotation marks around the word 'good'. Not too long ago, many others would not hesitate to put Noam Chomsky into the same category. But, since 9-11, the good professor exposed himself while answering questions like Who killed John F. Kennedy? and Who did 9-11 ? . Who knows? And who cares? - says zionist Chomsky.

Is there such a thing as a good Jew? What do you think? If there is, what is a good jew and what is it the good jew is trying to accomplish?

For one, I believed for a long time that Israel Shamir was a 'good' jew trying to educate the gullible gentiles about the nature of the jew; that is until I came across a piece by Shamir called "The Poverty of Racialist Thought":

http://www.israelshamir.net/English/Poverty.htm

If Shamir can convince us that race doesn't matter, that completely negates all his "education", does it not?

[Mike Parker]

Paul Craig Roberts is a Jew? Source?

[I v a n]

Originally Posted by Mike Parker

Paul Craig Roberts is a Jew? Source?

There is this very jew-wise guy named John Kaminski. A few years ago I had a short email exchange with him where I challenged his view that there is no such thing as a good jew. Since then my own views has moved steadily in a direction that got me closer to Kaminski's views.

In that email exchange Kaminski has identified Paul Craig Roberts as a jew (or crypto-jew, not sure if my memory serves me right). It's not that I believe everything Kaminski says. For example, Kaminski, or anyone else out there for that matter, could never convince me that Henry Ford, or Adolf Hitler, or Joseph Stalin, or Dr William Pierce, or George Rockwell and many others were jews or crypto-jews.

I do not have any "hard" proof that Paul Craig Roberts is what Kaminski says he is, but my intuition goes along very easily with that.

[Roy]

Asking if there is such a thing as a "Good Jew" is like asking if there is such a thing as a "Good Mafia Member" or a "Good Member of a Criminal Conspiracy". Their allegiance alone makes them evil, so the answer is no.

[Fred]

Short answer: "NO"

Long winded answer: "F@#k NO!"

[Marty Macaluso]

I don't believe there are any good Jews, but I might make a special exception in the case of Fred Scrooby.

[Eric Wright]

I would say

otto weininger

Otto_Weininger

was an very interesting Jew.

But the question is a flawed question to begin with, before they are good or bad they are Jewish. So "good" or ""bad" is irrelevant.

[I v a n]

Originally Posted by Eric Wright

I would say otto weininger was an very interesting Jew.

But the question is a flawed question to begin with, before they are good or bad they are Jewish. So "good" or ""bad" is irrelevant.

Good point, Eric, a non-linear answer from a thinking man. Never heard of otto weininger, but I shall look into the matter.

There is another fascinating jew (if he was a jew) - Bobby Fischer. No matter how much I looked at this personality I couldn't find anything jewish about him - the way he looked, the way he spoken, the way he behaved, the way he thought, the way he lived and the way he died - nothing.

YouTube- The Strange Life of Bobby Fischer

YouTube- The Strange Life of Bobby Fischer

[Eric Wright]

Originally Posted by I v a n

Good point, Eric, a non-linear answer from a thinking man. Never heard of otto weininger, but I shall look into the matter.

There is another fascinating jew (if he was a jew) - Bobby Fischer. No matter how much I looked at this personality I couldn't find anything jewish about him - the way he looked, the way he spoken, the way he behaved, the way he thought, he way he lived and the way he died - nothing.

YouTube- The Strange Life of Bobby Fischer

Fisher was Jewish, on his mother's side, and some say even his fathers side. I can see his Jewishness, in some of his actions. namely his early arrogance, his solutions for non-Jew races, specifically "give America to the red-man" stance.
I have been a chess-player, on and off, for about 15 years. So before i was Jew wise I was always a fan of Fischer, and after I became Jew-wise my view of him did not change much. He proved himself to be intelligent and somewhat decent by speaking out against his fellow tribesmen.

[Serbian]

Originally Posted by I v a n

Good point, Eric, a non-linear answer from a thinking man. Never heard of otto weininger, but I shall look into the matter.

There is another fascinating jew (if he was a jew) - Bobby Fischer. No matter how much I looked at this personality I couldn't find anything jewish about him - the way he looked, the way he spoken, the way he behaved, the way he thought, the way he lived and the way he died - nothing.

YouTube- The Strange Life of Bobby Fischer

I respect him for being brave enough to break the American/EU/UN sanctions on Serbia and publicly spitting in the face of ZOG. These were the most rigorous sanctions in the history of the UN and an arrest warrant was issued for him following the Spassky rematch.

He also hated jews with a passion, so yeah Bobby Fischer was ok.

1992 Spassky rematch

After twenty years, Fischer emerged from isolation to play Spassky (then tied for 96th–102nd on the FIDE rating list) to a "Revenge Match of the 20th century" in 1992. This match took place in Sveti Stefan and Belgrade, FR Yugoslavia, in spite of a United Nations embargo that included sanctions on sporting events. Fischer demanded that the organizers bill the match as "The World Chess Championship", although Garry Kasparov was the recognized FIDE World Champion. Fischer insisted he was still the true world chess champion, and that for all the games in the FIDE-sanctioned World Championship matches, involving Karpov, Korchnoi and Kasparov, the outcomes had been pre-arranged.[239] The purse for Fischer's re-match with Spassky was US$5,000,000, with $3.35 million of that to go to the winner.[240]

Fischer won the match, 10 wins to 5 losses, with 15 draws.[241] Many grandmasters observing the match said that Fischer was past his prime.[citation needed] Kasparov reportedly said, "Bobby is playing OK, nothing more. Maybe his strength is 2600 or 2650. It wouldn't be close between us."[242] Fischer never played any competitive games afterwards.[243] The last recorded chess game of Fischer's career occurred after the Spassky match, an informal game played with Woman International Master Cathy Forbes; Fischer won the game after Forbes blundered on her 27th move and resigned.[244]

Fischer and Spassky gave a total of ten press conferences during the match.[245] Yasser Seirawan wrote, "After September 23 [1992], I threw most of what I'd ever read about Bobby out of my head. Sheer garbage. Bobby is the most misunderstood, misquoted celebrity walking the face of the earth."[246][247] Seirawan wrote that Fischer is not camera shy, "smiles and laughs easily", and "is a wholly enjoyable conversationalist. A fine wit, he is a very funny man".[248]

The U.S. Department of the Treasury had warned Fischer beforehand that his participation was illegal as it violated President George H. W. Bush's Executive Order 12810[249] that implemented United Nations sanctions against engaging in economic activities in Yugoslavia.[250] In front of the international press, Fischer was filmed spitting on the U.S. order forbidding him to play. Following the match, the Department obtained an arrest warrant for him. Fischer remained wanted by the United States government for the rest of his life and never returned to the United States.

[Karl Radl]

Is there a 'good' serial killer?

No: simple as. If you let jews convince you that only some jews are 'bad' then it just means you do as the Christians churches did for centuries: deal with only part of the jewish population and get infiltrated by the other part who are quite happy to sell their kin down the river to make a quick profit or get a quick ego fix. Jews must be removed root and branch otherwise the plague returns: simple as that.

P.S. Any decent proof Alan Hart is a jew [I presume you mean the British journalist], because that is news to me and I can't see any immediate source for it on a brief google.

[I v a n]

Originally Posted by Karl Radl

Is there a 'good' serial killer?

No: simple as. If you let jews convince you that only some jews are 'bad' then it just means you do as the Christians churches did for centuries: deal with only part of the jewish population and get infiltrated by the other part who are quite happy to sell their kin down the river to make a quick profit or get a quick ego fix. Jews must be removed root and branch otherwise the plague returns: simple as that.

P.S. Any decent proof Alan Hart is a jew [I presume you mean the British journalist], because that is news to me and I can't see any immediate source for it on a brief google.

I do not know what your criterion for decent proof is, but see if this helps you to make up your mind one way or the other about the nature of Alan Hart:

http://www.radiofreemississippi.net/pdfs/marine.pdf

[Karl Radl]

Originally Posted by I v a n

I do not know what your criterion for decent proof is, but see if this helps you to make up your mind one way or the other about the nature of Alan Hart:

http://www.radiofreemississippi.net/pdfs/marine.pdf

And you claim to have a PhD?

That's not proof: that is an unreferenced opinion at best and more than likely pointless hearsay at worst. Decent merely meant something that can be either reasonably infered/deduced from; or can be verified by, a credible source.

Its like me saying you are a jew and then claiming some bloke I've seen has said that you are.

[Hilda]

"Is there such a thing as a good Jew?"
What you are asking is: is there a Jew that goes against the interests of the parasite race and who works against it?

For whom would that be "good"?

Is it required of them to go against their own kind to be "good"?

Of course a parasite dies with its host and there are better things to be than a parasite if you want your people to survive. But they are what they are. They can't escape it.

Always be suspicious of any that appear to rebel against their kind. Even though any with a remotely Aryan brain could not fail to be horrified and frightened by the inevitable consequences of that parasitism - and see it as being like a monkey sawing off the very branch on which it sits.

[Eric Wright]

Second thought on the subject; its a vague question. lets define the racial Jew first. NSDAP had the 1/4 law, a decent number of people with Jewish ancestry fought for and even believed in NS ideology. Also cases of dedicated Italian Fascist of Jewish ancestry.
I believe Hitler felt (going off memory here) that after 7 generations of extraction form Jewish DNA, that the toxins could be cleared.
Thoughts?