|
February 19th, 2013 | #1 | |
卐 ☠ ϟϟ ✠ 卐 ✠ ϟϟ ☠ 卐
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: In hell (also called multicultural USA)
Posts: 518
|
Grammatical Inquiry
Hey guys, I’d like your help with something that I’ve been trying to clarify for days to some unbelievably stubborn punk, whose planet-sized ego is so massive – that it just won’t accept that I’m right, and its owner is wrong, despite me having proven him wrong with a plentiful amount of evidence that I’ve provided him; which he refuses to even acknowledge. I’m by no means an English expert, and English is a secondary language to me, so I still have much to learn; but I’m always trying to improve as much as possible, and I know for a fact that I’m right about this one, because I’ve done a lot of research on it.
So, the issue this guy and I have being arguing about for days is about the rules for periods and commas when using quotation marks. I’ve been arguing that in American English – the rule is that periods and commas always go inside the quotation marks, regardless of personal logic. But he argues otherwise. He believes (and without providing ANY evidence whatsoever) that the text inside quotation marks must exactly duplicate the portion of the text that’s being quoted. In the examples below - the correct examples are the way I’d quote using commas and periods, and the incorrect examples show the way he’d do it: Quote:
Correct: “The hydroxyl groups the team detected are evidence that the lunar interior contained significant water during the moon's early molten state,” (Additional text follows here…) Incorrect: “The hydroxyl groups the team detected are evidence that the lunar interior contained significant water during the moon's early molten state”, (Additional text follows here…) Periods: Correct: “and may have played a key role in the development of lunar basalts.” (Additional text follows here…) Incorrect: “and may have played a key role in the development of lunar basalts”. (Additional text follows here…) There are multiple grammar-related websites out there that prove I'm right. Even the Modern Language Association (MLA) Handbook for Writers of Research Papers, which is widely used in the U.S., Canada, and other countries, for writing and documentation of research in English studies (including the English language, writing, and literature written in English), proves I'm right. Yet, this stubborn idiot insists that he's "right," and everyone and everything else is simply "wrong," and/or "retarded." Yeah, I know this is probably nothing to make a big deal out of, but I’d like to get some input from you guys on this, and help me clarify it. I’m a bit of a “Grammar Nazi,” who likes to type with immaculate English as much as possible, so I would be pretty upset if I’ve actually been using quotation marks with commas and periods incorrectly during all this time, ever since I began to learn to write in English. I just want to know if I’m right or wrong about this. P.S. WW14 (Justin), get your stubborn ass in this thread and prove me wrong if you can! |
|
February 19th, 2013 | #2 |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 310
|
"Commas and periods are always placed inside of quotation marks." (< as demonstrated)
|
February 19th, 2013 | #3 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 4,006
|
The grammar books are wrong.
What's being quoted should be to the left of the period. It should be up to the writer. Real differences, such as it's vs. its, do require hard and fast rules in order to communicate. Do those claiming the quotation marks should be outside give a reason? Or is it just custom? >>>Three thumbs up, one down Last edited by Rick Ronsavelle; February 19th, 2013 at 12:53 PM. |
February 19th, 2013 | #4 | ||
卐 ☠ ϟϟ ✠ 卐 ✠ ϟϟ ☠ 卐
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: In hell (also called multicultural USA)
Posts: 518
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
“The sweet Goddess of Peace lives only under the protective arm of the ready God of War.” ― David Lane
|
||
February 19th, 2013 | #5 | |
professional critter
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: under your bed
Posts: 1,618
|
Quote:
I thought (correct) English grammar rules were universal. "No whey dood," shout the illiterati. Enter the valdezian logic of extreme linguistic arbitrariness that deems wholly legitimate every possible corruption of the written and spoken word.
__________________
"Don't underestimate the power of 'evil.' ... The fact is, 'evil' makes women horny and men curious. Use those to further the cause." |
|
February 19th, 2013 | #6 |
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Saratoga, WY
Posts: 1,710
|
At least I've got one person agreeing with me, even though I don't know how reliable he is.
|
February 19th, 2013 | #7 | |
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Saratoga, WY
Posts: 1,710
|
Quote:
The punctuation should only ever go inside the quotation marks if the person quoted used them at the same place. |
|
February 19th, 2013 | #8 | |
Administrator
|
Quote:
|
|
February 19th, 2013 | #9 |
Banned
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 479
|
In a colloquial setting: inside.
In a more formal usage (such as paraphrasing): outside. |
February 19th, 2013 | #10 | |
Administrator
|
Quote:
|
|
February 19th, 2013 | #11 |
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Saratoga, WY
Posts: 1,710
|
|
February 19th, 2013 | #12 |
drinking tea
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: England
Posts: 38,898
|
I was always taught that if the text you are quoting ends with a punctuation mark, it should go inside the quotation marks. If it's your own punctuation mark, it goes outside. That was in an English school, though.
__________________
Above post is my opinion unless it's a quote. |
February 19th, 2013 | #13 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 8,645
|
I agree, the Brits got it right here. When I remember, I do it the British way.
BTW this is pretty much the only rule of grammar I deliberately flout.
__________________
Blood & Soul Aryan |
February 19th, 2013 | #14 | |
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Saratoga, WY
Posts: 1,710
|
Quote:
I'm half tempted to change my stance on it though just because Witzgall is agreeing. |
|
February 19th, 2013 | #15 |
drinking tea
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: England
Posts: 38,898
|
Also - inb4 Rick Ronsavelle:
Title should be "Grammatical Enquiry", surely?
__________________
Above post is my opinion unless it's a quote. |
February 19th, 2013 | #16 | |||
卐 ☠ ϟϟ ✠ 卐 ✠ ϟϟ ☠ 卐
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: In hell (also called multicultural USA)
Posts: 518
|
Quote:
Quote:
If you were born in the U.S., raised in the U.S., educated in the U.S., have been living in the U.S. your entire life, never have traveled outside the U.S., and speak and write in American English - you have no excuse to rely on British English just to favor one single argument of yours. It seems to me that the only reason why you can’t accept that in America English is written as I described in my first post, is because your goddamned stupid ego can’t ever accept that you made a mistake, and that I’ve been right all along. So, if you're going use British English exclusively for commas and periods with quotation marks, then you need to start adopting everything about British English, and integrate all their words, spelling, and dialects into your English too. (e.g. colour, flavour, harbour, honour, humour, labour, neighbour, rumour) Otherwise, stick to American, and accept American rules. I find it funny and sad how you criticize the Brits on so many things, but then use them as a life jacket whenever it’s convenient for you. I’ve already provided you with a ton of proof that crushes your argument, and pretty much everything I’ve researched related to American grammar agrees with me, yet you insist on denying the facts, because you’re the guy who’s “always right about everything.” Oh wait, I’m sorry. I believe you said “not always, just 99.9% of the time.” Why should it? Quote:
__________________
“The sweet Goddess of Peace lives only under the protective arm of the ready God of War.” ― David Lane
|
|||
February 19th, 2013 | #17 | ||
drinking tea
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: England
Posts: 38,898
|
Quote:
b) Quote:
http://oxforddictionaries.com/defini...nglish/enquire I trust the Oxford Dictionary over someone that references the Grauniad as a paragon of good usage! As for "there little discernible distinction in the way the two words are used today in British English" - well, that leads us down the road to txt speek and all sorts of invented words.
__________________
Above post is my opinion unless it's a quote. |
||
February 19th, 2013 | #18 |
卐 ☠ ϟϟ ✠ 卐 ✠ ϟϟ ☠ 卐
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: In hell (also called multicultural USA)
Posts: 518
|
@Bev:
Sorry; not going to change the title just for you, because there's nothing wrong with the title to begin with, and also - I did fully research the information and facts regarding my topic. Besides, I live in the U.S., and I've been learning American English for the last 10 years, and since I'm the one who started this thread - I reserve the right to name the title as I see fit, which is the American way.
__________________
“The sweet Goddess of Peace lives only under the protective arm of the ready God of War.” ― David Lane
|
February 19th, 2013 | #19 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 3,110
|
American English isn't really a language. It's more of a ... dialect. Or a creole, even.
Honestly, though, I don't care. The thing that bothers me is when someone starts mixing features of both 'types' of English. Like Aussies using American spelling; that pisses me off. |
February 19th, 2013 | #20 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 3,110
|
I say, the punctuation goes inside the quotation marks or the bracket:
"Because it's a lot neater this way." And a lot easier to edit, too! (See what I mean?) But that's my personal preference. I've tried both ways of doing it, and I think this is the better one. Of course, there are exceptions, such as when someone (an idiot), who doesn't know any better, tells me that I'm wrong. Or when you find a possum (trichosurus vulpecula), an unwelcome visitor to your home, making a mess while trying to fish desirable morsels from the rubbish bin. Last edited by M.N. Dalvez; February 19th, 2013 at 11:45 AM. |
Share |
Thread | |
Display Modes | |
|