Vanguard News Network
VNN Media
VNN Digital Library
VNN Reader Mail
VNN Broadcasts

Old December 13th, 2008 #1781
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,001
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by T.F. Scheb View Post
Muley said:
"Sure, if you manage to get the necessary government permissions for archaeological investigation. I would choose Sobibor for that, however - at Belzec you'd first have to remove the memorial."

What about Treblinka? Was it the end of the line or was it the end of the line?
Treblinka was the end of the line for transports taken there, just like Belzec and Sobibor, but like at Belzec there is the concrete of a huge memorial covering most of the former mass graves area at Treblinka, which would have to be removed first.

At Sobibor, on the other hand, the "ash mountain" memorial covers only a relatively small part of the area where the mass graves are located, and only a part of two of the seven mass graves in that area are under the memorial, as you can see below on a map by Prof. Kola and a satellite photograph section, both with my numbering of the graves according to Prof. Kola's description thereof.





So an archaeological investigation of the mass graves at Sobibor is comparatively easy. All it takes is the will, the expertise, the equipment (core drilling devices, shovels, maybe excavation machines for the deeper layers) and the required government permission to do so. The people of the Sobibor Archaeological Project are willing to do this work, they have the expertise and can obtain the necessary equipment. The problem is obtaining the permission, as the Polish government does not easily grant permissions to do archaeological work that involves disturbance of Polish memorial ground.
 
Old December 13th, 2008 #1782
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?

Nothing has changed since my last posts. Compulsive liar and whimpering coward retardo still hasn’t found even the little amount of courage required to engage in a discussion in which she also answers questions and complies with demands for evidence.

Poor retardo, things just keep getting worse for the pathetic loser.

We're still waiting for slurpin and the retarded rabbi to show us just one single photo of a single ounce of human remains.

To date, not an iota of human remains has ever been proven to have been located at Sobibor.

NOT AN IOTA!


* Remember, we're talking about remains that have been proven to be human and proven to have been found at Sobibor.

Just what part of the word PROVE don't you two idiots understand?

What are the jews waiting for? Is 65 years not enought time for them?

Now, since just 1/10th of 1% seems to be too hard for slurpin and retardo, lets see them answer the following questions:

Why has no one yet to locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.

?????

I think you can answer if you try real hard.

Can you try?

What are you afraid of?


BTW:

Have you ever asked Shermer for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


Have you ever asked Kola for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


Have you ever asked Freund for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


And why are you so afraid to answer these questions slurpin and retardo?:


Do you believe that millions of jews can vanish from the face of the earth without leaving a trace?


Do you believe in the "magically disappearing jew theory?"


Just what part of physically impossible do you not understand?


Why do the jews refuse to release the GPR results of their Sobibor investigation?


Why do the jews refuse to do their own GPR of Treblinka?


How about an inquiry on the rodoh forum?


Can't you ask nickfairy?


Not that hard.


Just one e-mail.


Just one.

What are you afraid of?

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 16th, 2008 at 06:24 PM.
 
Old December 13th, 2008 #1783
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?


Now slurpin and retardo, we're still waiting for you losers to answer the following:

Where did the soil came from for the construction of Sobibors "huge mound of human remains?"

Let's see the photos of the pits that would have resulted from digging out so much soil.

Let's see the photos of the construction of the monument that show one single ounce of human remains.

Let's see the Freund GPR results that would show EXACTLY where those alleged pits where the alleged human reminas were dug out of are.


Let's not forget:

"This summer [July, 2008], a team led by Richard Freund mapped the surface of the [Sobibor] camp using electromagnetics, magnetometry and ground-penetrating radar equipment... (Mapping the entire Sobibor camp was done by University of South Florida geography professor Philip Reeder) 'The idea is to figure out scientifically where everything was'... Freund said, who has been using the geophysical technology for a decade and is one of a small number of archeologists throughout the world to take advantage of its precision and speed to map sub-surfaces... Calgary based WorleyParsons geophysicists Paul Bauman and Brad Hansen used... [GPR] radar to create cross-sectional images of the site and detect areas of soil disturbance... 'Now we can know exactly... what’s there or if there’s nothing there,' says Freund, 'So this technology is really a godsend for archeology.'

'The Sobibor project is unique,' says team historian Avi Patt, in its synthesis of archeology and history of the Holocaust. 'There are very few cases of a place where you can do this kind of archeology,' he says. 'A camp has been buried, concealed from sight, and tried to be hidden, and you have to do a kind of detective work to find out where it was. There are Holocaust deniers who say, 'There never was a camp there, who knows if there was an extermination center?' Part of my motivation is to say, 65 years later, ‘No, you’re not going to get away with hiding this from history.’”


Oh, yeah, and of course we're still waiting for slurpen and the retarded rabbi to locate / prove the existence of just one single human tooth at Sobibor or Treblinka.

Can you do it losers?

Just one.

One.


Oh, let's not forget - here are the unanswered questions about Sobibor that the two losers refused to answer over on topix.


1 - On what EXACT date(s) was Michael Shermer physically in the Sobibor camp?

2 - Why does he refuse to reveal this date(s)?

3 - Are there photographs that prove he ever stepped foot in the camp?

4 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

5 - On what date can we expect Shermers report on his findings that resulted from his "firsthand investigation" of the camp?

6 - On what EXACT date(s) was Kola physically in the Sobibor camp?

7 - Why does he refuse to reveal this date(s)?

8 - Are there photographs that prove he ever stepped foot in the camp?

9 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

10 - Are there photographs of Kola actually excavating the alleged "huge mass graves?"

11 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

12 - Are there photographs proving that any "remains in a state of decay" actually exist?

13 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

14 - What were the results were of the analysis of those soil core samples?"

15 - On what date can we expect Kolas report on his findings that resulted from his "excavation" of the 7 alleged "huge mass graves?"

16 - What proof is there that the "huge mound of human remains" of Sobibor contains an iota of human remains?

17 - Where are the photographs of the construction of the "mountain of human ash?"

18 - What happened to the NON jew bones that were once in the glass display case at Sobibor?

19 - Why does the $100,000.00 - THE FINAL SOLUTION FORENSIC CHALLENGE reward go unclaimed?

20 - Is 1/10th of 1% too tough for you?


It is? OK, then let's make it even easier for you:

Can you locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.

?????

I think you can answer if you try real hard.

Can you try?

What are you afraid of?



Oh, and let's add one more question:

Where are the other 182 Sobibor Core Sample photos?

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 16th, 2008 at 06:24 PM.
 
Old December 13th, 2008 #1784
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?


T.F. Scheb:

"Will Muley go for the cash? Will she slink away in disgrace?"


She's doing something even more disgraceful than slinking away.

She's just refusing to answer any and all relevent questions that prove that there was no Sobibor or Treblinka holocausts.


T.F. Scheb:

Why doesn't retardo address Gerdes' questions with direct, straight forward answers?"what is she afraid of?"


Yes retardo, just what is it that you are afraid of?

Now answer my questions loser.

Let's remind everyone that even the retarded rabbi admits that there would be millions and millions of teeth (even lying around above ground) at the alleged "pure extermination centers." From his topix posts:

"I never claimed that the victims of Treblinka disappeared "without leaving a trace", on the contrary... I never claimed that all teeth were reduced to tooth meal, on the contrary... I provided two sources expressly mentioning teeth on the grounds of Treblinka... there’s no reason to assume that he was wrong about the above-mentioned teeth... Any particular reason why this should not be enough to conclude that teeth were lying around on the Treblinka site? My reasonable explanation for expecting teeth to have been among the human remains means they didn’t crush all of them, as I have pointed out over and over again, quite a few must have been overlooked. Duh!... A claim which I never made - that all teeth were crushed... Actually, as Gerdes well knows, I never claimed that the crushing of teeth at Treblinka led to the obliteration of all of these teeth. In the mass graves, according to Kola, "there were charred human remains and under them remains in a state of decay". These remains may well include teeth, lots of them."

Yeah, lots and lots - as in millions and millions.

However, even the dull one admits that not so much as one single tooth, out of an alleged 35 million, has ever been proven to exist at Sobibor or Treblinka.

Not one.

(BTW, the dullard ran away from the topix site with his tail between his legs.)

Seems being asked to provide proof of just 1/10th of 1% of the murder of 250,000 jews was just too hard a task for her.

And it seems like asking her to locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.


Is too much for her also.

OK then retardo -

HOW ABOUT JUST ONE TOOTH?

Just one dumb ass.

One.

Can you do it retardo?


So let's recap shall we?

The retarded rabbi has yet to locate / prove the existence of one ounce of human remains at Sobibor and/or Treblinka.

Not an ounce.

In fact, not an iota.

1.120 million jews alleged murdered and buried in two very small, precisely known, locations, and the loser can't locate a single grave, a single body, a single bone fragment or even so much as one single tooth.

What are you waiting for loser?

After all, you do want to put an end to holocaust denial - don't you?


Remember what your man O'Neil said retardo:

"It does not matter how big the crime is as such - it could have been 800,000 people or one person - the detection, or forensic investigation, is exactly the same as long as the correct procedures are adopted... Not only did they [the Nazi's] dig up all the bodies, burnt them and ground the bones up, but... they have been intact there for the last 60 odd years," he said.

Yet the loser can't locate / prove the existence of so much as one single grave that contains so much as one single tooth or bone fragment at Sobibor or Treblinka.

NOT ONE!

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 16th, 2008 at 06:25 PM.
 
Old December 13th, 2008 #1785
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

the retarded rabbi roberta:

"...there is the concrete of a huge memorial covering most of the former mass graves area at Treblinka, which would have to be removed first."

Liar.

You say "covering most."

If "most" of it is allegedly covered, then some of it must be uncovered.

Prove it.

Let's see you locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.


Just one dumb ass.

One.

Can you do it retardo?

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 16th, 2008 at 06:25 PM.
 
Old December 16th, 2008 #1786
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,001
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Default

What did Gerdes do in response to my post # 1778 under http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php...postcount=1778 ?

Well, just what I expected the compulsive liar and whimpering coward to do.

In posts # 1782 to # 1785, he copied and pasted yet another repetition of the imbecilic, irrelevant and mostly already answered crap that he has been hiding behind ever since my post # 1536 under http://206.41.127.17/showpost.php?p=...postcount=1536, again including at least one of his old lies (the one about my having run away from him on Topix, commented in my blog article under http://holocaustcontroversies.blogsp...th-update.html). He also mouthed off a little about my post # 1781 under http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php...postcount=1781 , in a lame attempt to get my attention again (he should have left that to his sock-puppet T.F. Sheb, who I would reply to just in case heís not a sock-puppet of Gerdes).

But he did not to the one thing he knows he has to do to break the "ignore" deadlock and get my discussion with him on this forum going again, to dig out the replies I have already provided on this thread to most of his idiotic questions and reply to the few I have not addressed yet because they were asked after I put Gerdes on ignore in my post # 1536 under http://206.41.127.17/showpost.php?p=...postcount=1536 . Iím talking about the short statement that reads:

"I am prepared to, from now on, also answer questions and respond to challenges myself, and to address my opponentís arguments and the evidence presented by my opponent (all of it)."


Fatso Gerdes:



it simply too much a



to post this simple statement.

So the ignore situation remains as concerns discussion on this forum.
 
Old December 16th, 2008 #1787
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?

Nothing has changed since my last posts. Compulsive liar and whimpering coward retardo still hasn’t found even the little amount of courage required to engage in a discussion in which she also answers questions and complies with demands for evidence.

Poor retardo, things just keep getting worse for the pathetic loser.

We're still waiting for slurpin and the retarded rabbi to show us just one single photo of a single ounce of human remains.

To date, not an iota of human remains has ever been proven to have been located at Sobibor.

NOT AN IOTA!


* Remember, we're talking about remains that have been proven to be human and proven to have been found at Sobibor.

Just what part of the word PROVE don't you two idiots understand?

What are the jews waiting for? Is 65 years not enought time for them?

Now, since just 1/10th of 1% seems to be too hard for slurpin and retardo, lets see them answer the following questions:

Why has no one yet to locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.

?????

I think you can answer if you try real hard.

Can you try?

What are you afraid of?


BTW:

Have you ever asked Shermer for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


Have you ever asked Kola for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


Have you ever asked Freund for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


And why are you so afraid to answer these questions slurpin and retardo?:


Do you believe that millions of jews can vanish from the face of the earth without leaving a trace?


Do you believe in the "magically disappearing jew theory?"


Just what part of physically impossible do you not understand?


Why do the jews refuse to release the GPR results of their Sobibor investigation?


Why do the jews refuse to do their own GPR of Treblinka?


How about an inquiry on the rodoh forum?


Can't you ask nickfairy?


Not that hard.


Just one e-mail.


Just one.

What are you afraid of?

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 20th, 2008 at 09:07 PM.
 
Old December 16th, 2008 #1788
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?


Now slurpin and retardo, we're still waiting for you losers to answer the following:

Where did the soil came from for the construction of Sobibors "huge mound of human remains?"

Let's see the photos of the pits that would have resulted from digging out so much soil.

Let's see the photos of the construction of the monument that show one single ounce of human remains.

Let's see the Freund GPR results that would show EXACTLY where those alleged pits where the alleged human reminas were dug out of are.


Let's not forget:

"This summer [July, 2008], a team led by Richard Freund mapped the surface of the [Sobibor] camp using electromagnetics, magnetometry and ground-penetrating radar equipment... (Mapping the entire Sobibor camp was done by University of South Florida geography professor Philip Reeder) 'The idea is to figure out scientifically where everything was'... Freund said, who has been using the geophysical technology for a decade and is one of a small number of archeologists throughout the world to take advantage of its precision and speed to map sub-surfaces... Calgary based WorleyParsons geophysicists Paul Bauman and Brad Hansen used... [GPR] radar to create cross-sectional images of the site and detect areas of soil disturbance... 'Now we can know exactly... what’s there or if there’s nothing there,' says Freund, 'So this technology is really a godsend for archeology.'

'The Sobibor project is unique,' says team historian Avi Patt, in its synthesis of archeology and history of the Holocaust. 'There are very few cases of a place where you can do this kind of archeology,' he says. 'A camp has been buried, concealed from sight, and tried to be hidden, and you have to do a kind of detective work to find out where it was. There are Holocaust deniers who say, 'There never was a camp there, who knows if there was an extermination center?' Part of my motivation is to say, 65 years later, ‘No, you’re not going to get away with hiding this from history.’”


Oh, yeah, and of course we're still waiting for slurpen and the retarded rabbi to locate / prove the existence of just one single human tooth at Sobibor or Treblinka.

Can you do it losers?

Just one.

One.


Oh, let's not forget - here are the unanswered questions about Sobibor that the two losers refused to answer over on topix.


1 - On what EXACT date(s) was Michael Shermer physically in the Sobibor camp?

2 - Why does he refuse to reveal this date(s)?

3 - Are there photographs that prove he ever stepped foot in the camp?

4 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

5 - On what date can we expect Shermers report on his findings that resulted from his "firsthand investigation" of the camp?

6 - On what EXACT date(s) was Kola physically in the Sobibor camp?

7 - Why does he refuse to reveal this date(s)?

8 - Are there photographs that prove he ever stepped foot in the camp?

9 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

10 - Are there photographs of Kola actually excavating the alleged "huge mass graves?"

11 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

12 - Are there photographs proving that any "remains in a state of decay" actually exist?

13 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

14 - What were the results were of the analysis of those soil core samples?"

15 - On what date can we expect Kolas report on his findings that resulted from his "excavation" of the 7 alleged "huge mass graves?"

16 - What proof is there that the "huge mound of human remains" of Sobibor contains an iota of human remains?

17 - Where are the photographs of the construction of the "mountain of human ash?"

18 - What happened to the NON jew bones that were once in the glass display case at Sobibor?

19 - Why does the $100,000.00 - THE FINAL SOLUTION FORENSIC CHALLENGE reward go unclaimed?

20 - Is 1/10th of 1% too tough for you?


It is? OK, then let's make it even easier for you:

Can you locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.

?????

I think you can answer if you try real hard.

Can you try?

What are you afraid of?



Oh, and let's add one more question:

Where are the other 182 Sobibor Core Sample photos?

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 20th, 2008 at 09:07 PM.
 
Old December 16th, 2008 #1789
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?


T.F. Scheb:

"Will Muley go for the cash? Will she slink away in disgrace?"


She's doing something even more disgraceful than slinking away.

She's just refusing to answer any and all relevent questions that prove that there was no Sobibor or Treblinka holocausts.


T.F. Scheb:

Why doesn't retardo address Gerdes' questions with direct, straight forward answers?"what is she afraid of?"


Yes retardo, just what is it that you are afraid of?

Now answer my questions loser.

Let's remind everyone that even the retarded rabbi admits that there would be millions and millions of teeth (even lying around above ground) at the alleged "pure extermination centers." From his topix posts:

"I never claimed that the victims of Treblinka disappeared "without leaving a trace", on the contrary... I never claimed that all teeth were reduced to tooth meal, on the contrary... I provided two sources expressly mentioning teeth on the grounds of Treblinka... there’s no reason to assume that he was wrong about the above-mentioned teeth... Any particular reason why this should not be enough to conclude that teeth were lying around on the Treblinka site? My reasonable explanation for expecting teeth to have been among the human remains means they didn’t crush all of them, as I have pointed out over and over again, quite a few must have been overlooked. Duh!... A claim which I never made - that all teeth were crushed... Actually, as Gerdes well knows, I never claimed that the crushing of teeth at Treblinka led to the obliteration of all of these teeth. In the mass graves, according to Kola, "there were charred human remains and under them remains in a state of decay". These remains may well include teeth, lots of them."

Yeah, lots and lots - as in millions and millions.

However, even the dull one admits that not so much as one single tooth, out of an alleged 35 million, has ever been proven to exist at Sobibor or Treblinka.

Not one.

(BTW, the dullard ran away from the topix site with his tail between his legs.)

Seems being asked to provide proof of just 1/10th of 1% of the murder of 250,000 jews was just too hard a task for her.

And it seems like asking her to locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.


Is too much for her also.

OK then retardo -

HOW ABOUT JUST ONE TOOTH?

Just one dumb ass.

One.

Can you do it retardo?


So let's recap shall we?

The retarded rabbi has yet to locate / prove the existence of one ounce of human remains at Sobibor and/or Treblinka.

Not an ounce.

In fact, not an iota.

1.120 million jews alleged murdered and buried in two very small, precisely known, locations, and the loser can't locate a single grave, a single body, a single bone fragment or even so much as one single tooth.

What are you waiting for loser?

After all, you do want to put an end to holocaust denial - don't you?


Remember what your man O'Neil said retardo:

"It does not matter how big the crime is as such - it could have been 800,000 people or one person - the detection, or forensic investigation, is exactly the same as long as the correct procedures are adopted... Not only did they [the Nazi's] dig up all the bodies, burnt them and ground the bones up, but... they have been intact there for the last 60 odd years," he said.

Yet the loser can't locate / prove the existence of so much as one single grave that contains so much as one single tooth or bone fragment at Sobibor or Treblinka.

NOT ONE!

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 20th, 2008 at 09:08 PM.
 
Old December 16th, 2008 #1790
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?

the retarded rabbi roberta:

"...there is the concrete of a huge memorial covering most of the former mass graves area at Treblinka, which would have to be removed first."

Liar.

You say "covering most."

If "most" of it is allegedly covered, then some of it must be uncovered.

Prove it.

Let's see you locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.


Just one dumb ass.

One.

Can you do it retardo?

Last edited by Greg Gerdes; December 20th, 2008 at 09:10 PM.
 
Old December 19th, 2008 #1791
T.F. Scheb
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 46
T.F. Scheb
Default

Roberto said:
"Treblinka was the end of the line for transports taken there, just like Belzec and Sobibor, but like at Belzec there is the concrete of a huge memorial covering most of the former mass graves area at Treblinka, which would have to be removed first."

Are you saying that people brought to Treblinka were exterminated? Also, when was this concrete memorial constructed?
 
Old December 20th, 2008 #1792
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,001
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Default

What did Gerdes do in response to my post # 1786 under http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php...postcount=1786 ?

Well, just what I expected the compulsive liar and whimpering coward to do.

In posts # 1787 to # 1790, he copied and pasted yet another repetition of the imbecilic, irrelevant and mostly already answered crap that he has been hiding behind ever since my post # 1536 under http://206.41.127.17/showpost.php?p=...postcount=1536, again including at least one of his old lies (the one about my having run away from him on Topix, commented in my blog article under http://holocaustcontroversies.blogsp...th-update.html). He also mouthed off once more about my post # 1781 under http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php...postcount=1781 , in a lame attempt to get my attention again (he should have left that to his sock-puppet T.F. Sheb, who I would reply to just in case heís not a sock-puppet of Gerdes).

But he did not to the one thing he know he has to do to break the "ignore" deadlock and get my discussion with him on this forum going again, to dig out the replies I have already provided on this thread to most of his idiotic questions and reply to the few I have not addressed yet because they were asked after I put Gerdes on ignore in my post # 1536 under http://206.41.127.17/showpost.php?p=...postcount=1536 . Iím talking about the short statement that reads:

"I am prepared to, from now on, also answer questions and respond to challenges myself, and to address my opponentís arguments and the evidence presented by my opponent (all of it)."

Fatso Gerdes:



it too much a



to post this simple statement.

So the ignore situation remains as concerns discussion on this forum.
 
Old December 20th, 2008 #1793
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,001
Roberto Muehlenkamp
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by T.F. Scheb View Post
Roberto said:
"Treblinka was the end of the line for transports taken there, just like Belzec and Sobibor, but like at Belzec there is the concrete of a huge memorial covering most of the former mass graves area at Treblinka, which would have to be removed first."

Are you saying that people brought to Treblinka were exterminated?
Yes, because thatís what all known evidence (including but not limited to the evidence mentioned in my posts 172 under http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php...&postcount=172 , 194 under http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php...&postcount=194 and 777 under http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php...&postcount=777 ) shows to have happened, with no evidence whatsoever pointing to an alternative scenario.

Quote:
Originally Posted by T.F. Scheb View Post
Also, when was this concrete memorial constructed?
In the 1960s, according to http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/...3913/Treblinka :

Quote:
In the 1960s, Poland erected an impressive monument at Treblinka. Comprising 17,000 stones, it outlines the shape of the death camp. Concrete blocks resembling railroad ties mark the entrance to the camp where the railroad cars were brought in. A large stone arch marks the gas chamber, and a sunken, blackened stone sculpture marks the site where the bodies were burned.
This is from a NYT article under http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpag...=&pagewanted=3 :

Quote:
In his book "The Texture of Memory: Holocaust Memorials and Meaning," James E. Young describes the Treblinka memorial "as perhaps the most magnificent of Holocaust memorials."

Built in the 1960's, it resembles an immense graveyard. Some 17,000 jagged chunks of granite surround a looming, 26-foot-high stone pillar cleft from top to bottom by a vertical crack. In this symbolic graveyard, individual "gravestones" memorialize entire communities.
Further details about the memorial can be found under http://www.scrapbookpages.com/poland...nka/index.html .

Under http://fcit.usf.edu/Holocaust/resour...y/TREBLINK.htm you find photos of what the memorial looks like at present.
 
Old December 20th, 2008 #1794
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?

Nothing has changed since my last posts. Compulsive liar and whimpering coward retardo still hasnít found even the little amount of courage required to engage in a discussion in which she also answers questions and complies with demands for evidence.

Poor retardo, things just keep getting worse for the pathetic loser.

We're still waiting for slurpin and the retarded rabbi to show us just one single photo of a single ounce of human remains.

To date, not an iota of human remains has ever been proven to have been located at Sobibor.

NOT AN IOTA!


* Remember, we're talking about remains that have been proven to be human and proven to have been found at Sobibor.

Just what part of the word PROVE don't you two idiots understand?

What are the jews waiting for? Is 65 years not enought time for them?

Now, since just 1/10th of 1% seems to be too hard for slurpin and retardo, lets see them answer the following questions:

Why has no one yet to locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.

?????

I think you can answer if you try real hard.

Can you try?

What are you afraid of?


BTW:

Have you ever asked Shermer for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


Have you ever asked Kola for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


Have you ever asked Freund for a copy of his study?

Ever?

Just once?

What are you afraid of?


And why are you so afraid to answer these questions slurpin and retardo?:


Do you believe that millions of jews can vanish from the face of the earth without leaving a trace?


Do you believe in the "magically disappearing jew theory?"


Just what part of physically impossible do you not understand?


Why do the jews refuse to release the GPR results of their Sobibor investigation?


Why do the jews refuse to do their own GPR of Treblinka?


How about an inquiry on the rodoh forum?


Can't you ask nickfairy?


Not that hard.


Just one e-mail.


Just one.

What are you afraid of?
 
Old December 20th, 2008 #1795
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?


Now slurpin and retardo, we're still waiting for you losers to answer the following:

Where did the soil came from for the construction of Sobibors "huge mound of human remains?"

Let's see the photos of the pits that would have resulted from digging out so much soil.

Let's see the photos of the construction of the monument that show one single ounce of human remains.

Let's see the Freund GPR results that would show EXACTLY where those alleged pits where the alleged human reminas were dug out of are.


Let's not forget:

"This summer [July, 2008], a team led by Richard Freund mapped the surface of the [Sobibor] camp using electromagnetics, magnetometry and ground-penetrating radar equipment... (Mapping the entire Sobibor camp was done by University of South Florida geography professor Philip Reeder) 'The idea is to figure out scientifically where everything was'... Freund said, who has been using the geophysical technology for a decade and is one of a small number of archeologists throughout the world to take advantage of its precision and speed to map sub-surfaces... Calgary based WorleyParsons geophysicists Paul Bauman and Brad Hansen used... [GPR] radar to create cross-sectional images of the site and detect areas of soil disturbance... 'Now we can know exactly... whatís there or if thereís nothing there,' says Freund, 'So this technology is really a godsend for archeology.'

'The Sobibor project is unique,' says team historian Avi Patt, in its synthesis of archeology and history of the Holocaust. 'There are very few cases of a place where you can do this kind of archeology,' he says. 'A camp has been buried, concealed from sight, and tried to be hidden, and you have to do a kind of detective work to find out where it was. There are Holocaust deniers who say, 'There never was a camp there, who knows if there was an extermination center?' Part of my motivation is to say, 65 years later, ĎNo, youíre not going to get away with hiding this from history.íĒ


Oh, yeah, and of course we're still waiting for slurpen and the retarded rabbi to locate / prove the existence of just one single human tooth at Sobibor or Treblinka.

Can you do it losers?

Just one.

One.


Oh, let's not forget - here are the unanswered questions about Sobibor that the two losers refused to answer over on topix.


1 - On what EXACT date(s) was Michael Shermer physically in the Sobibor camp?

2 - Why does he refuse to reveal this date(s)?

3 - Are there photographs that prove he ever stepped foot in the camp?

4 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

5 - On what date can we expect Shermers report on his findings that resulted from his "firsthand investigation" of the camp?

6 - On what EXACT date(s) was Kola physically in the Sobibor camp?

7 - Why does he refuse to reveal this date(s)?

8 - Are there photographs that prove he ever stepped foot in the camp?

9 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

10 - Are there photographs of Kola actually excavating the alleged "huge mass graves?"

11 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

12 - Are there photographs proving that any "remains in a state of decay" actually exist?

13 - If so, then why does he refuse to release them?

14 - What were the results were of the analysis of those soil core samples?"

15 - On what date can we expect Kolas report on his findings that resulted from his "excavation" of the 7 alleged "huge mass graves?"

16 - What proof is there that the "huge mound of human remains" of Sobibor contains an iota of human remains?

17 - Where are the photographs of the construction of the "mountain of human ash?"

18 - What happened to the NON jew bones that were once in the glass display case at Sobibor?

19 - Why does the $100,000.00 - THE FINAL SOLUTION FORENSIC CHALLENGE reward go unclaimed?

20 - Is 1/10th of 1% too tough for you?


It is? OK, then let's make it even easier for you:

Can you locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.

?????

I think you can answer if you try real hard.

Can you try?

What are you afraid of?



Oh, and let's add one more question:

Where are the other 182 Sobibor Core Sample photos?
 
Old December 20th, 2008 #1796
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?


T.F. Scheb:

"Will Muley go for the cash? Will she slink away in disgrace?"


She's doing something even more disgraceful than slinking away.

She's just refusing to answer any and all relevent questions that prove that there was no Sobibor or Treblinka holocausts.


T.F. Scheb:

Why doesn't retardo address Gerdes' questions with direct, straight forward answers?"what is she afraid of?"


Yes retardo, just what is it that you are afraid of?

Now answer my questions loser.

Let's remind everyone that even the retarded rabbi admits that there would be millions and millions of teeth (even lying around above ground) at the alleged "pure extermination centers." From his topix posts:

"I never claimed that the victims of Treblinka disappeared "without leaving a trace", on the contrary... I never claimed that all teeth were reduced to tooth meal, on the contrary... I provided two sources expressly mentioning teeth on the grounds of Treblinka... thereís no reason to assume that he was wrong about the above-mentioned teeth... Any particular reason why this should not be enough to conclude that teeth were lying around on the Treblinka site? My reasonable explanation for expecting teeth to have been among the human remains means they didnít crush all of them, as I have pointed out over and over again, quite a few must have been overlooked. Duh!... A claim which I never made - that all teeth were crushed... Actually, as Gerdes well knows, I never claimed that the crushing of teeth at Treblinka led to the obliteration of all of these teeth. In the mass graves, according to Kola, "there were charred human remains and under them remains in a state of decay". These remains may well include teeth, lots of them."

Yeah, lots and lots - as in millions and millions.

However, even the dull one admits that not so much as one single tooth, out of an alleged 35 million, has ever been proven to exist at Sobibor or Treblinka.

Not one.

(BTW, the dullard ran away from the topix site with his tail between his legs.)

Seems being asked to provide proof of just 1/10th of 1% of the murder of 250,000 jews was just too hard a task for her.

And it seems like asking her to locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Sobibor or Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.


Is too much for her also.

OK then retardo -

HOW ABOUT JUST ONE TOOTH?

Just one dumb ass.

One.

Can you do it retardo?


So let's recap shall we?

The retarded rabbi has yet to locate / prove the existence of one ounce of human remains at Sobibor and/or Treblinka.

Not an ounce.

In fact, not an iota.

1.120 million jews alleged murdered and buried in two very small, precisely known, locations, and the loser can't locate a single grave, a single body, a single bone fragment or even so much as one single tooth.

What are you waiting for loser?

After all, you do want to put an end to holocaust denial - don't you?


Remember what your man O'Neil said retardo:

"It does not matter how big the crime is as such - it could have been 800,000 people or one person - the detection, or forensic investigation, is exactly the same as long as the correct procedures are adopted... Not only did they [the Nazi's] dig up all the bodies, burnt them and ground the bones up, but... they have been intact there for the last 60 odd years," he said.

Yet the loser can't locate / prove the existence of so much as one single grave that contains so much as one single tooth or bone fragment at Sobibor or Treblinka.

NOT ONE!
 
Old December 20th, 2008 #1797
Summer
WN Mother
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Ireland
Posts: 2,469
Summer
Default

Because the kike can't come up with a lie quick enough. Ran out of fresh ideas maybe. Maybe he has told the same bs story for so long, he never thought of how to respond when confronted by people who know the truth.
__________________
jews do NOT deserve to have the letter 'j' capitalized, not even if it is the first word of a sentence.
 
Old December 20th, 2008 #1798
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

Why does the retarded rabbi refuse to answer my questions?

the retarded rabbi roberta:

"...there is the concrete of a huge memorial covering most of the former mass graves area at Treblinka, which would have to be removed first."

Liar.

You say "covering most."

If "most" of it is allegedly covered, then some of it must be uncovered.

Prove it.

Let's see you locate / prove the existence of just one single "huge mass grave" at Treblinka that contains just one:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.


Just one dumb ass.

One.

Can you do it retardo?
 
Old December 21st, 2008 #1799
Hadding
Senior Member
 
Hadding's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 3,247
Hadding
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Roberto Muehlenkamp View Post
The eyewitness evidence I provided he feebly tried to discredit, then chose to simply ignore it. The documentary evidence I provided he didn’t even dare to address. Therefore, and although he cannot show any rules or standards of criminal investigation and/or historical research whereby physical evidence is the only evidence that matters, he eventually went back to yelling for physical evidence and physical evidence alone.
It's because there has been a lot of lying on the Holocaustian side of this issue, some of it organized. Surely you know that.

There was also falsification of documents after the war.

If what people say is dubious, then you have to base your conclusions on physical evidence.

Last edited by Hadding; December 21st, 2008 at 01:09 PM.
 
Old December 21st, 2008 #1800
Greg Gerdes
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,129
Greg Gerdes
Default

the retarded rabbi:

"although he cannot show any rules or standards of criminal investigation and/or historical research whereby physical evidence is the only evidence that matters, he eventually went back to yelling for physical evidence and physical evidence alone"


Translation:

The Germans allegedly murdered 1.120 million jews and their remains are allegedly buried in two tiny, precisely known locations - yet I cannot locate / prove the existence of so much as one single alleged "huge mass grave." Nor can I locate / prove the existence of a single mass grave that contains so much as 1/10 of 1% of the alleged mass murder. Nor can I locate / prove the existence of a sinlge grave that contians so much as one single:

1 - Complete human body in a "wax fat transformation."

2 - Complete human skeleton.

3 - Complete human skull

4 - Complete human bone.

5 - Human bone fragment.

6 - Human tooth.

7 - Ounce of human ash.

8 - Spent bullet.

9 - Shell casing.

Thus, my entire thesis is based on the magically disapearing jew "theory"
 
Reply

Share


Thread
Display Modes


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:44 AM.
Page generated in 0.23612 seconds.